2015
US Championship Cheese Contest
- Second: Vermont Clothbound Cheddar
International Cheese Awards
- Gold : Queen of Quality Clothbound Cheddar
- Silver: Queen of Quality Clothbound Cheddar
- Bronze: Silver Smoked Chili Cheddar
American Cheese Society
- Second: Vermont Clothbound Cheddar
Big E Gold Medal Cheese Competition
- Gold: Queen of Quality Clothbound Cheddar
- Silver: 2 Year Aged Cheddar
- Silver: Maple Smoked Cheddar
- Silver: Bear Hill
- Bronze: Vermont Leyden
- Bronze: Extra Mature Cheddar
- Bronze: Red Vask
- Bronze: Smoked Chili Cheddar
- Bronze: Truffle Cheddar
- Bronze: Vermont Clothbound Cheddar
2014
World Cheese Awards
- Super Gold: Bismark
- Super Gold: Shepsog
Big E Gold Medal Cheese Competition
- Silver: Bear Hill
- Silver: Shepsog
- Bronze: 3 Year Aged Cheddar
- Bronze: Queen of Quality Clothbound Cheddar
- Bronze: Clothbound Cheddar
- Bronze: Maple Smoked Cheddar
American Cheese Society
- First: Shepsog
- First: Queen of Quality Clothbound Cheddar
- Second: Bull Hill
- Third: 2 Year Aged Cheddar
- Third: Bear Hill
International Cheese Awards
- Trophy for Best USA Cheese – Queen of Quality Clothbound Cheddar
- Trophy for Best Ewe’s Cheese – Shepsog
- Gold: Queen of Quality Clothbound Cheddar
- Gold: Shepsog
- Silver: Bismark
- Silver: Vermont Leyden
- Bronze: Bull Hill
- Gold: Duet
World Cheese Championship Contest
- Bronze: Shepsog
2013
World Cheese Awards
- First: Shepsog
- First: Naked Cheddar
- Third: Bull Hill
- Third: Eweden
- Third: Vermont Leyden
American Cheese Society
- Best in Show 2nd Bear Hill
- First: Bear Hill
- Second: Vermont Clothbound Cheddar
- First: Apple Pie Eweden
International Cheese Awards
- Trophy Best Ewes Milk Cheese -Bear Hill
- First: Bear Hill
- Second: Bismark
- First: Truffled Bismark
- Third: Shepsog
- VHC: 4 year Cheddar
- Second: Vermont Leyden
The Big E Cheese Competition
- Second: Vermont Clothbound Cheddar
- Second: 1 year Cheddar
- Second: Vermont Leyden
- Third: Garlic Cheddar
- Third: Truffled Bismark
- Third: Duet
- Third: Red Vask
- Second: Maple Smoked Bismark
- Third: Maple Smoked Cheddar
- First: Barndance
- Third: Bear Hill
United States Championship Cheese Contest
- Third: Vermont Clothbound Cheddar
- Third: Shepsog
- Second: Bear Hill
2012
Worlds Cheese Awards
- Top 16 Super Gold: Shepsog
- First: Bismark
- First: Vermont Clothbound
- First: Naked
- Third: Barndance
American Cheese Society
- Third: Bear Hill
- Second: Apple Pie Eweden
- First: Bismark
The Big E cheese Competition
- Best in Show: Naked Cheddar
- First: Naked cheddar
- Second: Queen of Quality Clothbound Cheddar
- Second: 3 year Cheddar
- Third: Vermont Clothbound
- First: Truffled Bismark
- First: Sumac & Black Pepper Eweden
- First: Eweden
- First: Apple Pie Eweden
- Second: Vermont Leyden
- Third: Bear Hill
- Second: Maple Smoked Cheddar
- Second: Maple Smoked Bismark
- Second: Shepsog
- Third: Bismark
2011
World Cheese Awards
- First: Vermont Clothbound Cheddar
- Third: Truffled Bismark
- Third: Barndance
- Third: Red Vask
- Third: Shepsog
American Cheese Society
- Second: Grafton Duet
The Big E Cheese Competition: 4 Awards
2010
American Cheese Society
- First: Maple Smoked Cheddar
- Second: Quercus Vitis Humulus Cheddar
- Third: Vermont Ice Cider Cheddar
The Big E Cheese Competition: 4 Awards
World Cheese Championship Contest
- First: Bandaged Cheddar
- First: Mixed Milk Mold Ext.
- Second: Bandaged Cheddar (aged)
2009
American Cheese Society
- Third: Cypress Cheddar
- Third: Half Ewe Blue Farmhouse
- Second: Agrippina Feta
- Second: Colbaa w/Truffle
- Third: Colbaa w/Ginger & Scallion,
- Third: Colbaa
- First: Leiden
US Jersey Cheese Competition
- Second Best of Show Blau Wein Kase
- Gold: Blau Wein Kase
- Silver: Natural Rind Cheddar, Cypress Cheddar, Paris1853
- Bronze: Ocheese, Cilantro Leyden, Aztec Cheddar
US Cheese Championship Contest
- Second: Blue Farmhouse
- Third: Cypress Cheddar
2008
American Cheese Society
- First: Caraway Cotija
2007
American Cheese Society
- Second: Dante
- Third: Mona
2006
American Cheese Society
- Best in Class: Dante
